One could view A Woman Is a Woman (Une Femme Est Une Femme), Jean-Luc Godard’s second film, as a bold experiment in filmmaking or so much self-important hoo-hah. I think it’s both.
Here’s the deal: Godard’s first film, Breathless (written off here), was a huge success, marking him as a major innovator of the French New Wave of filmmaking. I think the experience empowered Godard and compelled to keep innovating, to keep finding new ways of telling a story. With A Woman Is a Woman, however, his new way includes silly, distracting tricks and unflattering cinematography of ridiculous people making poor decisions.
What kind of silly, distracting tricks? Early in the film, the lead character (Anna Karina – more on her later) passes behind a pillar and undergoes an instantaneous costume change, one on which she comments. Thereafter, we notice every time she passes behind an obstruction, waiting a beat to learn whether she changes again. It pulls us out of the movie. Later, Karina and her dumber-than-rocks boyfriend have an argument with a silly gimmick: they aren’t speaking, so they pull books off their shelves and show one another words from the covers to express their feelings. Give me a break.
What kind of unflattering cinematography? In his later Vivre Sa Vie (appreciated here), Godard uses black and white film to make star Anna Karina an epic beauty of endless fascination. Here, his choice of garish color accentuates Karina’s nicotine-stained teeth and makes us recoil every time she smiles.
And what kind of ridiculous people making poor decisions? I can’t even describe the plot of this film without sounding needlessly condescending, so you’re going to have to discover that for yourself, should you feel so inclined. Let’s just say that I couldn’t believe that any sane woman would do the things Karina does in this film, and I’m not sure whether Godard expected me to.
So why call this a bold experiment, or even anoint it as hoo-hah, when it seems so obviously a failure? I think we can do so because Breathless indicated a filmmaker capable of crafting a coherent and well-designed film, and Vivre Sa Vie indicated a filmmaker capable of crafting a masterpiece. I think Godard was in control of his material, and I think he was feeling sufficiently self-important to try new ways of telling a story and showcasing characters. Sometimes, experiments fail: A Woman Is a Woman was such a time.
